🍕 Pete’s Pizza

What they’re all about is pretty simple: fresh, no-frills pizza made daily. They roll their own dough in-house and focus on classic, crowd-pleasing toppings rather than anything overly fancy or trendy. The menu leans heavily into traditional pizza, wings, and sides, and they’ve built a reputation for being budget-friendly and reliable, especially for takeout or delivery.

Locally, Pete’s has that “grew up eating this” kind of reputation. People often mention the generous toppings (especially their pepperoni pizzas) and solid wings, and it’s known as a dependable go-to for quick, filling food rather than a gourmet experience. Because there are several locations—like Pete’s Pizza on Bunting, Pete’s Pizza on Lakeshore, and Pete’s Pizza on Merritt—you’ll find slight differences depending on the store, but the overall style stays consistent.

The vibe:
Think classic Canadian pizza joint—nothing fancy, open late, big portions, and easy on the wallet.

Bottom line:
Pete’s Pizza is a reliable, long-time local staple in St. Catharines. If you’re after a straightforward, satisfying pizza and wings night without overpaying, it’s one of those places that just gets the job done—and has been doing it for years.

If you want, I can tell you how it stacks up against places like Maestros or OddBar—those comparisons get interesting real fast